Of course it is a values judgement, and I am sure you have a few things you think are ridiculous.
I think it is ridiculous because objective reality is not a democracy. It does not matter how many people earnestly believe that water is something other than H2O - water is and always will be H2O.
It also does not matter how many people earnestly believe in the big bang or young earth creation (ie the earth being 6000 years old, the flood created all the geography, etc) - these things either did or did not happen (and since they are mutually exclusive either one of them did or neither of them did - both of them happening is not an option!)
Whether something is debunked or not is a matter of objective fact - whether/why you choose to believe it is debunked or not is a matter of opinion or faith or belief for sure. The 2 things are separate and different.