"Mouse" in Space (Ice?)

Source: https://youtu.be/l8W19r5m_GU?t=2605


At 43:24 in the above live stream of the SpaceX CRS-19 Launch, something slides around the engine. Someone remarked that this looked a bit like a mouse, and some of the more imaginative conspiracy theorists took this to be evidence that the footage was faked.
SpaceX-CRS-19-Launch-Live.gif
The video is shot from two sides, alternating between viewpoints, which makes it difficult to follow exactly what is going on. But it's much clearer if we take just the shots from the "mouse" side, zoom in, and speed them up 10x.

Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tnbSMjFebPk

A real time version of this is here.

Here we see the "mouse" build up at the top, then break free and slide around. It's followed by a bunch more of what looks like slushy ice (possibly actual ice - or some other byproduct of the jet engine that built up around that point, maybe from what is venting near the top of the image). This slides around and looks like it maybe melts a bit.

So, a fascinating display of space physics. But not a mouse.

[Update Jan 18 2020]

It's not ice, it's actually solid oxygen. The white jet at the top is venting liquid oxygen, which is what causes the build-up of solid oxygen.

People why the oxygen does not just boil off into space. The answer is that some of it does, and what's left freezes. The principle is called "Vacuum freezing". Below the triple point of oxygen (or water, etc), it can only exist only as a solid and gas. A vacuum is obviously below the triple point in terms of pressure. So in the vented liquid oxygen the high energy molecules rapid boil away, cooling down the remaining liquid, which will solidify. Putting liquid oxygen into a vacuum is actually HOW YOU MAKE solid oxygen. Here's a demonstration with oxygen:
Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6RRLBD1bB3E


And similar with water:
Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ti9C_cLSR0A
 
Last edited:

Comments

You can see the ice start forming on the camera that's on the opposite side of the "mouse shot" at 41:12, just after the second stage ignites. By about 41:36 the ice has grown significantly in size. Around 42 minutes you can see it start separating from the vents and moving around the engine nozzle. At 42:10 when the camera switches to the opposite side again you can see the ice that had built up is no longer there; it has already separated and begun sliding around the nozzle. It may also be helpful to point out that this isn't unique to this launch; you can see ice separating from vents on the second stage in just about any given SpaceX launch. You can also see ice sliding around the top of the turbopump exhaust wraparound of the nozzle at around 19:28 in this video from CRS-16 launch. It's smaller and more spread out, but it's there:
Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Esh1jHT9oTA

Larger chunks are visible at 23:51 in this video from the CRS-14 launch:
Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BPQHG-LevZM

These are just a couple daytime launches I checked at random, one other I checked focused on the first stage recovery at LZ-1 rather than the second stage video so it was not visible.
 
I am truly left wondering how anyone, even someone who otherwise believes NASA and SpaceX are "faking space" could consider this to be even remotely reasonable. What exactly is the scenario here? Some little mouse snuck onto the hypothetical "fake rocket" stage and proceeded to walk around on the engine? Meanwhile, the hypothetical CGI guys are at once good enough to put together a video of a rocket orbiting the Earth, but are also so blindingly incompetent as to leave a literal mouse in frame.

How does one even debunk people who are willing to make, frankly, insane claims?
 
You can't... Because then you just become a "Schill" and are now part of the problem.
Sometimes the best you can do is just put accurate information out there for the people on the fence to see and/or to demonstrate just how off-base the original claimants are.
 
I tend to view things from an evolutionary perspective. I think our ancient brains can easily make a small moving thing into an animal, and thus a potential meal. Our brains are pattern matching machines.
 
Top